United Kingdom
UK
Search
Close this search box.

What the FCA Case Means for Global Policies

Carriers, brokers, underwriters, and everyone involved in the carrier industry face consistent pressure from consumers to ensure their policies are simple to understand, effective and trusted by policy holders. The recent Financial Conduct Authority case in the United Kingdom has brought this issue to light again, with three core concerns around policy wording raised. Read on to explore the global impact of these findings. 

It is a common perception that insurance policies are complex, challenging, and designed to skew in favour of carriers. While those of us in the insurance industry believe this isn’t true, we still have significant work ahead of us to overcome this perception and offer trusted, well-received and comprehended policies.  

The recent Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) case in the United Kingdom brought this issue to light again, with the Court’s comments making it clear policy wording had shaped the outcome of this case, with more than 700 policies likely to be impacted.  

This is an issue we expect to continue to play out around the world, as cases testing the strength of business interruption policies, in light of COVID, conclude and social inflation continues to grow. 

There were three core areas the UK FCA case raised which we expect to see mirrored in other regions: 

 

1) Disease exclusions 

The Court found that these exclusions were often overlooked when it came to updating policies and queried what value the policy could offer if it did not cover the impact of disease. It also questioned whether COVID could be excluded as it was not a general disease, and the restrictions around whether a disease had presented close to the claimant’s business were criticised. The carrier’s argument was that it was impossible to prove a single, local case of COVID impacted a business, but this was negated by the Supreme Court’s finding that each and every case of COVID was an equally effective cause of the government’s reaction to the pandemic.  

 

2) Prevention of access or general exclusion clauses 

Policies with these clause types were relied upon by carriers to expressly provide against cover, but where the Court found this failed was that exclusions cannot apply where a carrier has given an express grant of cover with one hand and taken it away with another. 

It is understandably confusing for a policy holder to read they are both covered and not covered, but this judgement will have far-reaching consequences for the industry. Hundreds of policies make specifications around what can and can’t be claimed for, and if we can no longer state general exclusions it will have major impacts to claim costs. 

 

3) Quantification argument 

The Court found carriers excluded or removed the benefits of coverage by arguing the insured risk was limited to the number of cases in that specific area, so there would have been minimal or no loss because the business may not have been impacted at all by local cases. But, the Court argued that due to its issues with disease exclusions, insurers would now need to consider what position claimants would be in if we were in a COVID-free world. 

 

So, where to from here? 

Carriers need to ensure they, and any of their suppliers or TPAs, are across changes to legislation and business interruption test cases in their region. As an industry, we also need to consider how we build and present policies to policy holders and whether they are truly fit for purpose in a world that has drastically changed.  

Reach out to one of our experts to talk more about how Gallagher Bassett ensures it delivers best-practice outcomes. 

Jennifer Turner

Managing Director – GB Technical

More Posts

Insights

What’s Next for ESG: Six Expert Tips for Insurers in 2024

One key topic that has gained significant regulatory interest in the insurance sector is ESG. As new regulations and reporting standards emerge, insurers are facing increased pressure to adapt. Ashley Easen, Director of Risk and ESG, shares invaluable strategies for insurers to navigate these changes, build trust, and safeguard their reputation.

Read more
Insights

Building Storm Resilience: Five Tips for Surge Claim Readiness

The past few weeks have seen adverse weather hit the UK, and floods pose unique challenges, demanding insurers tailor response plans specifically for these scenarios. As the UK contends with extreme weather conditions, we bring you five tips to preparing a robust storm surge support plan.

Read more
Insights

The Talent Tide: Attracting and Retaining New and Established Talent

In the new world of work, organisations are witnessing a shifting tide in the convergence of both emerging and established talent. To support insurers to effectively attract and retain diverse talent, Gordon Vater, Managing Director – GB Technical, shares the essential strategies for navigating the shifting talent tide.

Read more
Insights

Customer Service: Preparing for the Festive Season and Learnings from the 2023 Customer Satisfaction Index

With the end of the year fast approaching, insurers are eagerly looking forward to the holiday season after facing various challenges this year in the insurance industry. At the same time, as 2023 begins to wrap up, it’s common to see increasing customer complaints as cost-of-living stress and claims delays set in. Beth Povey, Chief Compliance Officer, sat down to share her expert insights on how to best navigate the end-of-year season by leveraging the latest Customer Satisfaction Index to your advantage.

Read more

Keep your finger on the pulse of the latest industry news and insights.

Sign up to our monthly newsletter today.

Download Our Global Insurance Industry Whitepaper

Hi there!

Want to drop us a line?  You can get in touch by filling out the form below and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible!